Stephen Merchant vs Robert Carlock

2011 Outstanding Comedy Series · 63rd Emmys
both lost to Modern Family
2010 Outstanding Comedy Series · 62nd Emmys
both lost to Modern Family
2009 Outstanding Comedy Series · 61st Emmys
Robert Carlock
2008 Outstanding Comedy Series · 60th Emmys
Robert Carlock
2007 Outstanding Comedy Series · 59th Emmys
Robert Carlock
2007 Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series · 59th Emmys
both lost to Greg Daniels