Noah Wyle vs Eriq La Salle

4 shared categories

• 1998 Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series · 50th Emmys
  both lost to Gordon Clapp
• 1998 Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film · 55th Golden Globes
  both lost to George C. Scott
• 1997 Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series · 49th Emmys
  both lost to Héctor Elizondo
• 1995 Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series · 47th Emmys
  both lost to Ray Walston

Named on the same nomination

Ballot lines that credit both of them — the same nomination, not competing entries.

• 2001 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 7th SAG Awards
• 2000 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 6th SAG Awards
• 1999 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 5th SAG Awards Won
• 1998 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 4th SAG Awards Won
• 1997 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 3rd SAG Awards Won
• 1996 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 2nd SAG Awards Won
• 1995 Ensemble in a Drama Series · ER · 1st SAG Awards

Nominated for the same title

Both nominated in connection with these, on separate ballot lines.

• ER Noah Wyle Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film, Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series
  Eriq La Salle Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film, Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series