Jesse Tyler Ferguson vs Ed O'Neill

3 shared categories

• 2013 Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series · 65th Emmys
  both lost to Tony Hale
• 2012 Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series · 64th Emmys
  both lost to Eric Stonestreet
• 2011 Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series · 63rd Emmys
  both lost to Ty Burrell

Named on the same nomination

Ballot lines that credit both of them — the same nomination, not competing entries.

• 2017 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 23rd SAG Awards
• 2016 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 22nd SAG Awards
• 2015 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 21st SAG Awards
• 2014 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 20th SAG Awards Won
• 2013 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 19th SAG Awards Won
• 2012 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 18th SAG Awards Won
• 2011 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 17th SAG Awards Won
• 2010 Ensemble in a Comedy Series · Modern Family · 16th SAG Awards

Nominated for the same title

Both nominated in connection with these, on separate ballot lines.

• Modern Family Jesse Tyler Ferguson Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series
  Ed O'Neill Male Actor in a Comedy Series, Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series