Brian d'Arcy James vs Gregg Edelman

1 shared category

• 2002 Best Featured Actor in a Musical · 56th Tonys
  both lost to Shuler Hensley

Nominated for the same title

Both nominated in connection with these, on separate ballot lines.

• Into the Woods Brian d'Arcy James Best Actor in a Musical
  Gregg Edelman Best Featured Actor in a Musical